Written by: Editorial Team, Bangalore Shoulder Institute
Medically Reviewed by: Dr. Ayyappan V. Nair
Senior Consultant – Shoulder Surgery, Arthroscopy and Sports Trauma
Manipal Hospitals, Bangalore
Last Reviewed: 15th November 2026
A focal cartilage lesion is a localised patch of damaged cartilage on the humeral head, the ball of the shoulder joint, while the cartilage around it stays healthy. The top of the ball meets the socket when the arm hangs at the side and moves through the early arc of lifting, so even a small defect here can produce a deep, mechanical ache. Cartilage has no blood supply of its own and heals poorly. A patch that starts small can therefore deepen or loosen under continued loading. The cause, the size of the lesion and the health of the bone beneath it determine which treatments remain open.
One Damaged Patch, Not a Worn-Out Joint
Arthritis wears cartilage across both the ball and the socket. A focal lesion is a contained defect with healthy cartilage on either side, often in a joint that is otherwise normal. A joint with one damaged patch can sometimes be repaired or resurfaced locally, whereas widespread wear usually cannot. Left untreated, the edges of a lesion can fray and the exposed bone can be irritated by joint fluid. Some shoulders go on to develop wider damage, although how often this happens is not well quantified.
Two Routes to a Damaged Humeral Head Surface
Two separate pathways lead to these lesions, and they are managed differently. In the first, the injury is to the cartilage itself. In the second, the bone beneath fails first.
Mechanical injury. A dislocation or a fracture of the humeral head can drive the ball against the socket rim and bruise or shear off a piece of cartilage. In throwers, swimmers and gymnasts, repeated high-speed loading concentrates stress on the same patch of surface, and the cartilage breaks down from accumulated microtrauma. The result is a sharply defined defect, often in an otherwise healthy joint.
Bone-driven disease. Avascular necrosis can follow long-term steroid use, heavy alcohol intake, sickle cell disease or certain fractures. The blood supply to the bone under the cartilage is disrupted, the bone weakens and collapses, and the cartilage above loses its support and cracks. Osteochondritis dissecans is uncommon in the shoulder and affects adolescents whose growth plates are still open. A segment of bone and its cartilage cap loses its blood supply, softens and can detach. Because these problems begin in the bone, the assessment has to look at the bone as carefully as the cartilage.
Signs That Point to the Joint Surface
Symptoms overlap with rotator cuff and labral problems. These features help point towards the cartilage:
- A deep, poorly localised ache at the top or front of the shoulder that worsens with overhead reaching or throwing
- Catching, clicking or a brief snagging sensation as the arm moves, most often when a loose flap or fragment is present
- Night pain, especially when lying on the affected side
- In young athletes, a gradual loss of throwing distance or speed, with pain that no longer settles after rest
- Reasonably preserved strength when pain allows it, whereas a rotator cuff tear usually produces more obvious weakness when lifting the arm
Why a Normal Scan Does Not Settle the Question
X-rays are the usual first test. They are often normal in early disease, although they can show flattening or collapse when bone is involved. MRI is the main investigation, but the top of the humeral head contains a normal bare area near the rotator cuff attachment where cartilage is naturally absent, and it can be mistaken for a defect. MRI can also miss small cartilage lesions, so a normal result does not rule one out when the symptoms fit. MR or CT arthrography, where contrast is injected into the joint, shows the cartilage surface more clearly. Arthroscopy (keyhole inspection) confirms the lesion, measures it and allows treatment in the same sitting when appropriate.
Matching the Treatment to the Lesion
Most people start without surgery. Reducing provocative loading, working with a physiotherapist on rotator cuff and shoulder blade control, and using simple pain relief can settle symptoms in smaller or stable lesions. In adolescents with a stable osteochondritis dissecans lesion, a period of reduced loading with repeat imaging gives growing bone a better chance of healing than adult bone has. Injections can ease pain but do not repair cartilage.
When symptoms persist or a fragment is loose, surgery is considered. The choice depends on lesion size, bone involvement and age.
Situation | Option | What to Expect |
Small lesion with frayed or loose edges | Arthroscopic debridement | Smooths flaps and removes loose fragments to stop catching; does not regrow cartilage |
Small to medium defect, healthy bone beneath | Microfracture (marrow stimulation) | Small channels let marrow cells form repair tissue; this fibrocartilage is softer than the original |
Defect involving bone, or earlier treatment failed | Osteochondral graft (autograft or allograft) | Fills the defect with a plug of bone and cartilage; limited by graft availability and healing |
Large defect in an older patient, or collapse from avascular necrosis | Partial resurfacing or joint replacement | Replaces the damaged surface when preserving the joint is no longer realistic |
Evidence for cartilage restoration in the shoulder rests mainly on small case series, and long-term results are less established than in the knee. Surgeons therefore weigh the options individually and discuss that uncertainty openly.
Recovery and Return to Sport
Rehabilitation after cartilage surgery protects the repair first and rebuilds movement and strength second. Microfracture and graft procedures generally need a longer protected phase than debridement, with time in a sling and a delay before loading. Return to overhead or throwing sport is measured in months. Loading a repair that is still maturing risks failure of the repair and a return of symptoms.
What Parents of Young Athletes Should Watch For
A teenager who keeps training through a deep shoulder ache can turn a stable lesion into an unstable one. Parents who notice a drop in throwing performance, a child protecting the arm, or pain lasting beyond a couple of weeks of rest should arrange a review with an orthopaedic or sports medicine specialist.
Cartilage is invisible on a standard X-ray and heals poorly, so these lesions are easy to miss and slow to announce themselves. A shoulder that aches deep at the top, catches, and does not settle with rest deserves imaging chosen to examine both the cartilage and the bone beneath it. The size of the lesion and the health of that bone at diagnosis set the options available.
For enquiries and online appointments, send a message to www.DrAyyappanVNair.com/contact
For informative videos related to Shoulder problems and their treatment options, Sports Injuries and other orthopedic conditions, visit our YouTube channel Bangalore Shoulder Institute – https://www.youtube.com/@BangaloreShoulderInstitute

